.
Feedback

Greenburgh Meeting Tonight about Tappan Zee High Line

tzbridge park

Fred Schaeffer, father of the very successful Walkway over the Hudson(Poughkeepsie) will be the guest speaker at the organizational meeting to be held on Wednesday, November 16th at 8 PM at Greenburgh Town Hall to plan a lobbying effort to turn the old Tappan Zee bridge into a suburban high line when the new bridge is built. Mr. Schaeffer spent many years advocating for the walkway. Many people said it was not practical, could not work. But—Mr. Schaeffer persisted. And, today the Walkway over the Hudson is one of the most popular tourist attractions in the Hudson Valley. The walkway over the hudson has been very helpful to  local businesses and to the economy.David Wilson of the Bike Walk Alliance of Westchester/Putnam will also speak. We expect to ask state officials to hire an independent structural engineer to review the feasibility of this proposal. White Plains Councilwoman Milagros Lecuona is co-chairing the task force. She has created a new website: www.tappanbridgepark.com.  Councilwoman Lecuona has 30 years of experience in architecture and urban planning.  It makes no sense to spend hundreds of millions of dollars to demolish the old TZ bridge when the bridge could be enjoyed by millions. I envision bicycle/pedestrian/skateboarding, possible gardens, sculptures, summer entertainment on the suburban high line. If you are interested in joining the committee – please e mail me at pfeiner@greenburghny.com.  The meeting will be held in the cafeteria of the Town Hall since another meeting is being held in the auditorium. My cell phone is 914 438 1343.

Newsletter & Alerts

Get the best stories each day and important breaking news

Subscribe

Not from Rivertowns Patch? Find your Local Patch »

George Bailey November 17, 2011 at 01:00 pm
It is great that people are trying to think outside of the box: removing an existing structure that has outlived its original purpose. There are several challenges with this idea, though. First, the High Line is in a densely developed portion of lower Manhattan and provides a park like setting in an environment that otherwise is concrete and paving. It connects with a number of buildings in which hundreds of thousands of people work and is close by where thousands more live. Without tourism, it has value and a viable use.
The Tappan Zee Bridge is much longer and connects the two shores of the river. While it does provide fabulous views up and down the river, as well as an interesting perspective of the shorelines, it does not share the vitality of activity adjacent to its span the way that the High Line does. It is also relatively steep. Driving over the bridge in a car obscures the fact that walking or biking over the bridge is quite an exercise. That is something that can be done now, but is daunting enough to keep the numbers of people interested in doing so very light. Since the current plan for the new bridge seems to be having trouble embracing the mandate that light rail be included in its construction, an alternative could be to consider the reuse of the old bridge for rail only. Since the structural steel seems in reasonable condition and the road bed structure the primary problem, using the bridge for trains should be investigated, with the road bed removed.
Sarita E November 17, 2011 at 01:48 pm
Actually, these issues were all addressed at last night's meeting. The slope is actually a very gentle one. Seen Walkway Over The Hudson? Go to walkway.org to see how an abandoned railroad bridge spanning the Hudson from Poughkeepsie to Highland was transformed. Since opening to the public in 2009, more than a million visitors have strolled, cycled, hiked, jogged, and roller-bladed over the Walkway.
Bruce Buckley November 17, 2011 at 06:16 pm
If the main reason for replacing the bridge is its deterioration and future safety risk, won't the same dangers exist for recreational use? Won't millions in tax money still be needed to maintain the bridge's structural integrity, and if that money is really available, which I doubt, wouldn't it be better spent for waterfront walkways and other recreational uses?
Blue November 17, 2011 at 09:00 pm
The view of the bridge on its own is a nice look but having it next to a newer structure would make for an eyesore. Not to mention all the costs and shipping lane hazards that would be incurred. Its nice to dream but it needs to go.
ASleepyBoy November 17, 2011 at 10:10 pm
Can you please substantiate this comment regarding the slope being very gentle? Everything I have read, studied and experienced would lead to the exact opposite conclusion.
Please let us know what you would consider a "gentle slope". Is it ADA accessible???
Sarita E November 18, 2011 at 01:04 am
Again I quote David McKay Wilson of the Bike Walk Alliance: "That bridge has been rebuilt over the past decade with $500 million in public funds. It’s slated for another $1.3 billion in repairs by the time the last car crosses the bridge less than a decade from today.
That’s a huge investment in transportation infrastructure that we believe may still have substantial life if it comes time to dismantle the Gov. Malcolm Wilson Tappan Zee Bridge to build a second new cross-Hudson span." Like the High Line and The Walkway, finding public funding is difficult, but the option is attracting private funds, which both projects have successfully done. The rewards in both cases were huge.
Sarita E November 18, 2011 at 01:11 am
Replying to ASleepyBoy... Here I'm quoting David McKay Wilson, co-founder of the The Bike Walk Alliance of Westchester-Putnam: "Like many of you here, I’ve done the Wilson TZ on the annual October fundraising ride for the National Multiple Sclerosis Society. We’ve climbed the 1.2 percent grade – not 20 percent as reported inaccurately in the New York Times – and either coasted or pedaled down into Rockland."
ASleepyBoy November 18, 2011 at 03:51 pm
It is clearly not 20 percent but it is definitely more than 1.2 percent. Looking at the following link, you can see that there is a maximum slope of 3.08% on the Rockland approach. While this is definitely not a prohibitive slope, it is definitely not an easy one for such long distances. These things need to be considered because unlike the other bridges that have been converted to pedestrian use, the TZ would not be something that someone could take a leisurely stroll on, or push carriage over, or skateboard over, etc.
Granted, this is only in the center span area but, again, this needs to be fully considered. http://www.tzbsite.com/tzb-library/pdf-library/pdf-RVR-200808/RVR%20Appendix%20C/RVR%20Appendix%20C%2004.pdf
Sarita E November 18, 2011 at 05:32 pm
Replying to ASleepyBoy's Nov 18th post: Beautiful drawings I hadn't seen, so thanks. And that 3.08% maximum slope on the Rockland approach may indeed be accurate. But if I calculate correctly, even a 3% gradient results in a gain of just 8 inches for each 20 horizontal feet. That type of slope exists all around the Rivertowns and doesn't seem difficult for many people. So yes, it does need to be considered by the planners/designers, but I don't regard it as a deal-breaker.
ASleepyBoy November 18, 2011 at 06:40 pm
Fully agree, and I was glad I was able to find those documents. There are many others on that website dealing with the original EIS for the Tappan Zee corridor project.
Definitely not a deal breaker but this would have to be dealt with in a totally different manner. I am also not sure how this would all pan out visually. Two bridges designed to be next to each other is one thing, two new ones next to an old one that look nothing alike may start to look very cluttered.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors. Write a new post... What's up? Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell something
loretta oleck June 12, 2013 at 12:19 pm
She is coming in from Chicago for this performance at City Winery. She is an amazing performer andRead More singer.
loretta oleck June 12, 2013 at 01:08 pm
Here's a clip of Lynne Jordan who will be performing a tribute to Nina Simone on July 2nd!Read More http://youtu.be/vWyhyBMZ7eU
Monique Avakian June 15, 2013 at 06:38 am
Thanks, Loretta, for the info -- I will try to go! And, yes, Lisa, I do play the piano -- learningRead More jazz right now! :)
Lisa Buchman (Editor) June 6, 2013 at 02:55 pm
Thanks for posting this! Hopefully someone will be looking - I'll post to Facebook as well. Let usRead More know when she has a new gig!
Donna Roses June 5, 2013 at 06:03 pm
Mina, I don't know how to respond to you so please call with questions if you are interested inRead More renting either of those weeks. 917-623-6529. Donna
Donna Roses June 12, 2013 at 07:37 am
also August 30-September 6 is available.